Re: Overlay writable filesystem over r/o partition [long]

Ben Woodard (bwoodard@cisco.com)
Mon, 05 Jan 1998 21:39:53 -0800


You might want to take a look at a copy of "The design and
implemtation of the BSD 4.4 operating system." by Marshall Kirk
McKusick. I took a class about the interals of BSD from him last
semester and I will be taking the second semester of it starting in a
couple of weeks and there are many more things to consider when
stacking file systems on top of each other than you addressed. This is
not to say that you don't have a good idea. It is one thing that I
have sort targeted to implement in linux once I have come to
understand the linux source as well as I understand BSD. The
discussion in Kirk McKusick's book about stackable file systems is
quite good and covers most of the things that you need to consider in
implemting a system. They did a really good job in BSD they found that
they could stack file systems about 100 deep without much
overhead. Other attempts at stackable file systems such as Sun's
"Spring" operating system had abysmal performace at about 7 levels
deep. If you are truly interested. I wouldn't mind re-reading the
chapter and summarizing it for you.

-ben