Question on using MSI in PCI driver

[Roland Dreier]

I'm looking at implementing MSI/MSI-X support in a PCI device driver
I'm working on.  However, I've run into an issue with the MSI API that
I would like some clarification on.

When I call pci_enable_msi, since my device is MSI-X capable, the
kernel calls msix_capability_init, which works out the memory region
where vectors should be written and then calls request_region.  (In
fact it calls

             request_mem_region(phys_addr,
		dev_msi_cap * PCI_MSIX_ENTRY_SIZE,
		"MSI-X iomap Failure"))

which leads to a bizarre entry in /proc/iomem with the name "MSI-X
iomap Failure")

The problem is that if I follow the standard route in my driver and
call pci_request_regions() during init (since I want to claim my whole
device), the request_mem_region in msix_capability_init will fail.
Now, for my device, the MSI-X table happens to fall in the middle of a
BAR, and I need to access stuff on both sides of it in that BAR.  To
make things even worse for me, my device has two more BARs I want to claim.

So it seems I am forced to turn my nice clean pci_request_regions()
call into two calls to request_mem_region() (to get the beginning and
end of the BAR with the MSI-X table in it) and two more calls to
pci_request_region() (to get the other two BARs).

This isn't the end of the world but it feels suboptimal to me.  Anyone
have an idea for a better way to do this?  (I'm happy to write a patch
to the kernel if someone suggests how to change the MSI API)

Thanks,
  Roland
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/