Re: 2.2.7_andrea2.bz2

Harvey J. Stein (hjstein@bfr.co.il)
04 May 1999 02:58:04 +0300


Andrea Arcangeli <andrea@e-mind.com> writes:

> On 2 May 1999, Harvey J. Stein wrote:
>
> >Start thinking about them. 2.2.7_andrea3 seems to perform similarly to
>
> ;). Now that I know which is the bit of code who made the difference I
> would aks you to try out some other experimental change.
>
> Could you try this patch and see how does it performs compared to
> 2.2.7_andrea3? (note, the only difference between
> 2.2.7_andrea3 and 2.2.7_andrea4 is a bugfix NFS related, but you are not
> using NFS because otherwise you would have noticed the bug, so don't waste
> time trying 2.2.7_andrea4 ;).
>
> BTW, I missed the extraversion in the Makefile from the diff (too lazy ;).
>
> If it will be worse than 2.2.7_andrea3 I'll send you an incremental patch
> to see if it will make differences.

It seems to be fine. I can't really say that one is better than
the other. Smoother interactive performance would be nice to see, but
the system was usable during the tests (about the same as 227a3 &
226a2. Here are all the #s for the 50k tests:

test 1 - boot, login & run dbase on a file.
test 2 - boot, login, startx, run dbase on a file, bring up netscape,
edit in emacs, etc.

dbase program builds a gdbm database. See previous msgs for details.

Test 1 (noninteractive) Test 2 (interactive)
user sys elapsed worst 2nd user sys elapsed worst 2nd Feel
2.0.36 27.69 7.70 2:37.27 9.73 6.88 28.97 10.21 17:30.68 76.37 75.11 D
28.32 7.33 0:43.87 3.36 2.32
27.52 7.40 0:43.08 3.42 2.22

2.2.6 28.20 6.70 2:47.06 7.47 6.87 31.73 8.92 14:41.84 16.57 16.53 B
28.92 6.17 1:46.01 7.97 6.62
28.69 6.39 1:47.77 7.81 6.76

2.2.6arca1 28.66 7.73 1:24.43 13.85 9.06 30.07 9.62 10:45.50 65.61 45.63 B
29.15 7.82 1:15.55 13.38 8.74
28.37 7.85 1:12.91 13.33 7.24

2.2.6a2** 28.04 7.24 0:42.24 2.82 2.10 29.89 7.33 1:30.70 6.09 4.34 A
28.44 7.06 0:42.37 2.82 2.10 30.45 7.73 1:25.50 5.09 4.27
28.02 6.96 0:41.94 2.79 2.09 30.19 8.10 1:20.83 4.57 3.22
27.88 7.23 0:42.39 2.80 2.09* 29.50 8.38 2:36.11 28.08 11.74
32.26 8.00 1:06.17 3.10 2.87
33.31 7.97 1:10.71 3.22 2.69

2.2.6a4+ 28.46 6.15 0:41.76 2.65 1.97 29.67 7.07 2:46.26 37.86 19.04 B
29.46 6.37 0:42.00 2.67 2.00 29.30 6.89 4:04.15 55.05 46.47
28.78 6.06 0:41.05 2.65 1.99 29.99 7.29 3:59.11 42.70 41.36

2.2.7 28.24 6.42 2:54.85 7.48 7.26 30.44 8.01 8:35.93 37.33 31.97 B
28.10 6.48 1:47.62 7.85 6.94
28.86 6.18 1:49.14 7.99 6.98

2.2.7a2 28.25 6.25 0:41.27 2.64 2.00 29.24 7.03 3:26.01 47.64 18.21 B+
28.82 5.75 0:41.00 2.66 1.98
28.40 6.19 0:41.01 2.68 1.99

2.2.7a2a 28.39 6.13 0:41.23 2.67 1.98 31.03 6.91 3:58.71 52.15 25.37 A
28.76 5.74 0:40.89 2.67 1.97 30.71 6.45 2:01.42 12.16 11.98
28.32 5.61 0:40.28 2.67 1.95 31.59 7.30 2:14.57 8.48 6.65

2.2.7a3 27.63 6.65 0:41.77 2.65 1.99 30.06 6.70 1:30.26 6.40 6.04 A
28.70 6.44 0:41.50 2.67 1.98 29.55 6.38 0:44.10 2.78 2.00
28.53 6.07 0:40.99 2.63 1.95 28.23 7.15 0:55.61 2.94 2.72
28.51 6.12 0:41.05 2.65 1.96 29.94 6.47 1:15.56 3.43 2.81
29.78 7.18 1:14.48 3.89 3.23
31.33 6.58 0:48.99 2.96 2.12

2.2.7a5p1 28.12 6.50 0:42.81 2.96 2.21 29.34 6.93 1:50.42 13.40 11.94 A
28.73 6.49 0:43.01 3.01 2.23 30.09 6.40 0:45.91 3.22 2.26
27.88 6.16 0:41.70 2.95 2.19 29.40 6.55 0:45.39 3.03 2.47
28.37 6.69 0:45.36 3.05 2.36
30.20 7.00 1:02.88 3.58 2.53

-- 
Harvey J. Stein
BFM Financial Research
hjstein@bfr.co.il

- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to majordomo@vger.rutgers.edu Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/