Re: SCSI disk driver module spin-up problem (1.3.67)

Eric Youngdale (eric@aib.com)
Thu, 22 Feb 1996 20:18:20 -0500


>I wonder if it might not be more useful to only spin up drives when they
are
>actually needed, be it at mount time or even only upon actual access. This
>might be especially useful for drives used mainly as backup storage (e.g.
to
>keep source trees that only need to be accessed every other week)...

I guess I am not really in favor of spinning down disks all the
time.
Most of the wear and tear that decreases the lifetime of a disk is at
startup and shutdown, so unless there are power management reasons
(i.e. on a laptop), I think it is probably better to simply leave the
disks spinning all the time.

In principle, it would probably not be that harmful to perform
spinup/spindown on mount/unmount. Having an idle timer seems like a
dangerous idea to me, as you could wear out a disk in a real hurry.

>I expect that if support for spinning down scsi drives were to be added to
>the kernel, such an approach would have to be taken anyways. The scsi-idle
>patch available at sunsite, if it worked properly, would have basically
>provided this -- is anyone still working on this one? I haven't seen any

First I have heard of this one.

-Eric

-- 
"The woods are lovely, dark and deep.  But I have promises to keep,
And lines to code before I sleep, And lines to code before I sleep."