Re: [PATCH v2 2/4] PCI: plda: Get common codes from Microchip PolarFire host

[Minda Chen]

On 2023/7/27 20:02, Bjorn Helgaas wrote:
> On Thu, Jul 27, 2023 at 06:39:47PM +0800, Minda Chen wrote:
>> Add PLDA PCIe controller driver codes, Move them from Microchip
>> PolarFire PCIe host driver codes. And move pcie-microchip-host.c
>> to plda directory.
>> 
>> The change includes:
>> - copy the IP register marcos.
>> - Add related data structures of PCIe host instance.
>>   mc_pcie --> plda_pcie (Get most of data members)
>>   mc_msi  --> plda_msi
>>   add plda_pcie_ops and plda_evt data structures.
>> - function rename list:
>>   mc_pcie_enable_msi       --> plda_pcie_enable_msi
>>   mc_pcie_setup_window     --> plda_pcie_setup_window
>>   mc_pcie_setup_windows    --> plda_pcie_setup_iomems
>>   mc_pcie_init_irq_domains --> plda_pcie_init_irq_domains
>>   mc_allocate_msi_domains  --> plda_allocate_msi_domains
>>   mc_init_interrupts       --> plda_pcie_init_irq
>>   msi interrupts related functions and irq domain
>>   (primary function is mc_handle_msi):
>>   mc_handle_msi            --> plda_handle_msi
>>   intx interrupts related functions and irq domain
>>   (primary function is mc_handle_intx):
>>   mc_handle_intx           --> plda_handle_intx
>>   event interrupts:
>>   mc_handle_event	   --> plda_handle_event
>> - For PolarFire implements non-plda local interrupt events, most of
>>   event interrupt process codes can not be re-used. PLDA implements
>>   new codes and irq domain ops like PolarFire.
>>   New event functions:
>>     plda_event_handler
>>     plda_pcie_event_map
>>     plda_ack_event_irq
>>     plda_mask_event_irq
>>     plda_unmask_event_irq
>>     plda_hwirq_to_mask
>> - plda_handle_event adds a new irqnum to event num mapping codes for
>>   PLDA local event except DMA engine interrupt events. The DMA engine
>>   interrupt events are implemented by vendors. So do not add these
>>   events. PolarFire PCIe uses get_events function pointer to get
>>   their events num.
> 
> There's a lot going on here, which makes this hard to review.  If
> possible, I suggest splitting this into multiple patches:
> 
>   - Move code to plda/ directory with no other changes
>   - Rename structs/functions from mc_* to plda_* with no other changes
>   - Add PolarFire-specific code
> 
Yeah, This is a lot modification. I will try to split more patches to get it easier
to review. maybe split IP register macros first, second rename structs/function only.
third add the new event mapping codes， at last add PolarFire-specific codes.
> Other general things:
> 
>   - Capitalize PLDA, IRQ, INTx, MSI, PCIe in commit logs, comments,
>     dmesg text
>   - Sort MAINTAINERS entries alphabetically; see
>     https://git.kernel.org/linus/c192ac735768
> 
ok
> Bjorn