Re: [PATCH v2] cpu/hotplug: Set st->cpu earlier

[Thomas Gleixner]

On Tue, Mar 22 2022 at 15:59, Vincent Donnefort wrote:
> On 22/03/2022 15:31, Thomas Gleixner wrote:
>> On Wed, Mar 16 2022 at 15:36, Steven Price wrote:
>>> Setting the 'cpu' member of struct cpuhp_cpu_state in cpuhp_create() is
>>> too late as other callbacks can be made before that point.
>> 
>> What?
>> 
>>          CPUHP_OFFLINE = 0,
>>          CPUHP_CREATE_THREADS,
>> 
>> The create threads callback is the very first callback which is invoked
>> for a to be plugged CPU on the control CPU. So which earlier callback
>> can be invoked and fail?
>> 
>> Thanks,
>> 
>>          tglx
>
>
> CPUHP_CREATE_THREADS itself can fail, before st->cpu is set.

Sure. But that does not explain the problem.

> Also, that value is used outside of the callbacks (cpuhp_set_state()
> in _cpu_up()).

And why on earth is this not spelled out in the changelog?

> But indeed this description could be refined a bit.

Indeed. But the description is not the only problem here:

It's completely uncomprehensible from the code in _cpu_up() _WHY_ this

     st->cpu = cpu;
     
assignment has to be there.

It's non-sensical if you really think about it, right?

That said, I'm pretty sure you can come up with:

 - a proper one time initialization of @st which solves your problem

 - a proper changelog which explains it

Thanks,

        tglx