RE: [PATCH v2 1/3] x86/mce: Avoid infinite loop for copy from user recovery

[Luck, Tony]

>> Maybe the other difference in approach between Andy and me is whether to
>> go for a solution that covers all the corner cases, or just make an incremental
>> improvement that allows for recover in some useful subset of remaining fatal
>> cases, but still dies in other cases.
>
> Does that mean more core code surgery?

Yes. I need to look at other user access inside pagefault_disable/enable()
as likely spots where the code may continue after a machine check and
retry the access.  So expect some more "if (ret == ENXIO) { do something to give up gracefully }"

>> I'm happy to replace error messages with ones that are more descriptive and
>> helpful to humans.
>
> Yap, that: "Multiple copyin" with something more understandable to users...

I'll work on it. We tend not to have essay length messages as panic() strings. But I can
add a comment in the code there so that people who grep whatever panic message
we choose can get more details on what happened and what to do.

-Tony