Re: [PATCH 1/2] Input: synaptics-rmi4 - clear irqs before set irqs

[Aaron Ma]

On 4/3/19 12:16 AM, Christopher Heiny wrote:
> On Thu, 2019-03-28 at 14:02 +0800, Aaron Ma wrote:
>> Hi Dmitry and Chiristopher:
>>
>> Do you have any suggestion about these 2 patches?
>>
>> Many users confirmed that they fixed issues of Trackpoint/Touchpad
>> after S3.
>>
>> Will you consider them be accepted?
> Hi Aaron,
> 
> Sorry - I thought I'd replied on the NO SLEEP portion of these patches,
> but looking back I don't find the draft or the sent email.  Sorry about
> that.  I'll summarize here what I wrote last month.
> 
> This isn't so much a "fix" as a "hacky workaround" for the issue.  From
> the descriptions in the bug you linked in your original patch
> submission, it appears that the root cause is somewhere in SMBus system
> (could be SMBus driver, SMBus hardware, or the devices on the SMBus
> (touch devices or other devices) - it's hard to tell with the info
> available), where the SMBus is failing to come online correctly coming
> out of S3 state.  Anyway, this patch doesn't fix the root cause, but
> merely works around it.

Users confirmed the 1st patch that clear irq status fixed their multiple
issues on Touchpad and Trackpoint.
I think it is a fix.

NO SLEEP patch was tried to give users a choice a fix touchpad issues
that I didn't reproduce.
If you don't like this export, we can drop it now as users confirmed 1st
patch works.

> 
> Setting the NO SLEEP bit will force the touch sensor to remain in a
> high power consumption state while the rest of the system is in S3. 
> While not a lot of power compared to things like the CPU, display, and
> others, it is still non-trivial and will result in shorter time-on-
> battery capability.

Verified on s2idle and S3 and system running idle mode. no difference on
power consumption of whole system with or without set 1 to nosleep.

> 
> If you have access to the power pin(s) for the touch sensor(s)/styk(s),
> it might be interesting to try turning power off on entering S3, and
> restoring it on exit.  That's very hacky, and has the side effect of
> slightly delaying touchpad readiness on exit from S3.  Plus you'll need
> to restore touch sensor configuration settings on exit.  But it
> definitely reduces power consumption.
> 
> 
> Separately, I am still concerned about the possibility of dropped touch
> events in the IRQ clearing.  I'm not convinced that the code is safe
> (as you mentioned in your reply to my earlier comment), so I'll have to
> study the implementation more carefully.

Sure, take your time, if you have any questions let me know please.

Thanks,
Aaron

> 
> 					Cheers,
> 						Chris
> 
> 
> 
>> Thanks,
>> Aaron
>