Re: [PATCH V5] leds: trigger: Introduce a USB port trigger

[Pavel Machek]

On Thu 2016-09-15 15:33:19, RafaÅ MiÅecki wrote:
> On 15 September 2016 at 14:56, Pavel Machek <pavel@xxxxxx> wrote:
> > On Fri 2016-09-09 13:31:10, RafaÅ MiÅecki wrote:
> >> On 9 September 2016 at 13:05, Greg KH <gregkh@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> >> > On Fri, Sep 09, 2016 at 05:34:40PM +0800, Peter Chen wrote:
> >> >> On Thu, Sep 08, 2016 at 06:08:24PM +0200, RafaÅ MiÅecki wrote:
> >> >> > From: RafaÅ MiÅecki <rafal@xxxxxxxxxx>
> >> >> >
> >> >> > This commit adds a new trigger responsible for turning on LED when USB
> >> >> > device gets connected to the selected USB port. This can can useful for
> >> >> > various home routers that have USB port(s) and a proper LED telling user
> >> >> > a device is connected.
> >> >> >
> >> >> > The trigger gets its documentation file but basically it just requires
> >> >> > enabling it and selecting USB ports (e.g. echo 1 > ports/usb1-1).
> >> >> >
> >> >> > There was a long discussion on design of this driver. Its current state
> >> >> > is a result of picking them most adjustable solution as others couldn't
> >> >> > handle all cases.
> >> >> >
> >> >> > 1) It wasn't possible for the driver to register separated trigger for
> >> >> >    each USB port. Some physical USB ports are handled by more than one
> >> >> >    controller and so by more than one USB port. E.g. USB 2.0 physical
> >> >> >    port may be handled by OHCI's port and EHCI's port.
> >> >> >    It's also not possible to assign more than 1 trigger to a single LED
> >> >> >    and implementing such feature would be tricky due to syncing triggers
> >> >> >    and sysfs conflicts with old triggers.
> >> >> >
> >> >> > 2) Another idea was to register trigger per USB hub. This wouldn't allow
> >> >> >    handling devices with multiple USB LEDs and controllers (hubs)
> >> >> >    controlling more than 1 physical port. It's common for hubs to have
> >> >> >    few ports and each may have its own LED.
> >> >> >
> >> >> > This final trigger is highly flexible. It allows selecting any USB ports
> >> >> > for any LED. It was also modified (compared to the initial version) to
> >> >> > allow choosing ports rather than having user /guess/ proper names. It
> >> >> > was successfully tested on SmartRG SR400ac which has 3 USB LEDs,
> >> >> > 2 physical ports and 3 controllers.
> >> >> >
> >> >> > Another planned feature is support for LED reacting to the USB activity.
> >> >> > This can be implemented with another sysfs file for setting mode. The
> >> >> > default mode wouldn't change so there won't be ABI breakage and such
> >> >> > feature can be safely implemented later.
> >> >> >
> >> >>
> >> >> It has such driver at: drivers/usb/common/led.c
> >> >
> >> > Ugh, I thought I had seen something like this before...
> >> >
> >> > RafaÅ, can you just use this in-kernel code instead?
> >>
> >> I really don't think I can because of all the reasons I carefully
> >> listed in the commit message.
> >>
> >> Have you took a look at that simple driver? It does nothing I need.
> >> Its design doesn't allow implementing features I clearly listed in the
> >> commit message.
> >
> > In any case, the new driver should probably go near the old one, at
> > the very least.
> 
> I can do that. Anyone objects?

I did not have time to study your patches in detail. IIRC there was
something like "directory full of usb IDs". I'm not sure that's a way
to go.

								Pavel
-- 
(english) http://www.livejournal.com/~pavelmachek
(cesky, pictures) http://atrey.karlin.mff.cuni.cz/~pavel/picture/horses/blog.html