Re: [PATCH 2.6.19.2] r8169: support RTL8169SC/8110SC

[èæå]

Francois Romieu æå:

> edward_hsu@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx :
> [...]
>  
>
> > ANS_2:
> > So, do you think that it is a good idea to keep other vendos's PID and
> > DID in the part?
> >    
>
> Yes.
>  

ANS_3:

OK! I will do it.

> [...]
>  
>
> > ANS_2:
> >
> > Sure! You are right. RTL8110SC, RTL8111B and RTL8101E have modest
> > differences, now. However, RTL8101E is a PCI-E fast ethernet controller.
> > I don't think is a good idea to merge its Linux driver into r8168.c or
> > r8169.c. RTL8110SC is the final version of Realtek PCI gigabit ethernet
> > controller. Moreover, due to the increasing popularity of PCI-E, Realtek
> > is going to design several generations of PCI-E ethernet controllers to
> > satisfy customer requests. I have discussed this issue with my hardware
> > colleagues. They believe that both MAC register layout and tx/rx
> > descriptor layout will be changed a lot in new PCI-E ICs. Actually, they
> > already did. Therefore, the hardwares of RTL8111B(PCI-E gigabit
> > ethernet) and RTL8101E(PCI-E fast ethernet) will have frequent and
> > drastic changes. So, I think that it's a good moment to separate their
> > Linux drivers, and r8169.c can become stable.
> >    
>
> Well, code and facts will tell. :o)
>
> Since you asked for questions:
>
> - will the ~7k limit for the jumbo frames be fixed ? One can hardly call
>  it a feature.
>  
ANS_3:

Realtek does implement 7k limit for jumbo frames. I think there is no standard to require how large a jumbo frame should be implemented.


> - out of curiosity, did you try the current in-kernel r8169 driver with
>  a 8111B or a 8101E ?
>  
ANS_3:
Yes I did! I tried Linux kernel 2.6.19. It seems that r8169.c supports 
RTL8111B and RTL8101E.

> - is there any plan to open the programming manuals of the PCI-E chipsets ?
>  
ANS_3:
Realtek does not have the plan to open  the programming manuals of the 
PCI-E chipsets.
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/