reiserfs performance loss

From: Eric Olson (
Date: Fri Oct 12 2001 - 14:54:47 EST

Dear Hans and linux-kernel,

I am experiencing read performance loss of between 5 to 20 times
due to what I think is data fragmentation in big files.

I am using linux-2.4.4 with the linux-2.4.4-knfsd-6.g.patch on a
dual processor VIA694 motherboard system with a 40GB Maxtor drive
on the builtin IDE controller DMA enabled and 512MB main memory.

The reiserfs partition is 31GB and about 60-70% full. Also, tail-
packing has not been disabled.

My application consists of 8 programs tied together using MPI.
Each program opens a separate output file and periodically writes
about 200k of data every 10-40 minutes. Some programs run on
remote machines and use the kernel nfsd to write their files on
the server; other programs run directly on the server. It is
possible all 8 programs write at the same time.

In this way 8 data files of about 500MB each are created.

For backup these data files are copied to a second server using
rsync. The second server is identical to the main server in both
hardware and software. Running hdparm -t gives about 20 MB/sec
for each machine. However,

        time cat *.dat >/dev/null

reads the data locally on the secondary server 5 to 20 times faster
than reading them locally on the main server.

Main server timings are

        real 6m26.789s
        user 0m0.210s
        sys 0m9.630s

and secondary server timings are

        real 0m34.358s
        user 0m0.250s
        sys 0m9.830s

This is 11 times speed difference. I think the original copies of
the files are quite fragmented. However, I would have expected at
most a two fold decrease in actual performace. Is this reasonable?

I have experienced no other difficulties with reiserfs and like it
very much.

All the best, Eric
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to
More majordomo info at
Please read the FAQ at

This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Mon Oct 15 2001 - 21:00:46 EST